Smyrna & Chattanooga(615) 237-5700Call now Smyrna (Nashville & Middle TN) office
Need cameras, access control or alarms?Visit Turner Security

Microsoft 365 Security Settings Every Small Business Should Turn On

By the TechCore team · · 6 min read

IT administrator at a desk reviewing Microsoft 365 security settings on a laptop in a small office, with a phone showing a sign-in approval prompt

Short answer: Start with multifactor authentication for everyone, using Microsoft's free security defaults or, if you have Microsoft 365 Business Premium or another plan with Entra ID P1, Conditional Access policies. Then make sure old sign-in methods that can't do MFA are blocked, set automatic forwarding to outside addresses to Off, give admins separate admin accounts, confirm audit logging is on and make sure someone receives Microsoft's built-in alerts. If you have Defender for Office 365, turn on the preset security policies. Most of this costs nothing extra, but none of it helps if nobody checks that it's set.

Microsoft 365 ships with good security tools. The catch is that many tenants were set up years ago, by someone who has since moved on, with settings that were never revisited. Here is what to check, in plain terms, as of late 2026.

Which settings matter most?

Setting What it does License needed Where it lives
Security defaults or Conditional Access Requires MFA and blocks risky sign-ins Security defaults: any plan. Conditional Access: Entra ID P1 (included in Business Premium) Microsoft Entra admin center
Block legacy authentication Stops old sign-in methods that skip MFA Included in both options above Microsoft Entra admin center
External auto-forwarding set to Off Stops mail from quietly forwarding to outside inboxes All plans with Exchange Online Microsoft Defender portal, outbound spam policy
Separate admin accounts Keeps admin rights off everyday email accounts All plans Microsoft 365 admin center
Audit logging on Records sign-ins, mailbox changes and admin actions Audit (Standard) on most business plans Microsoft Purview portal
Preset security policies Turns on Microsoft's recommended email protection Stronger options with Defender for Office 365 Microsoft Defender portal
Alert policies with a real recipient Sends warnings about forwarding rules, admin changes and blocked senders Built in Microsoft Defender portal

Security defaults or Conditional Access: which one do I need?

Both require multifactor authentication (MFA). The difference is control.

Security defaults are free and work on any license. When they're on, every user has to register for MFA, administrators must use MFA every time they sign in, everyone else is prompted when Microsoft sees a reason to, and legacy authentication is blocked. You can't customize them; they're either on or off. Microsoft turns security defaults on for new tenants, but older tenants and tenants that had them switched off may not have them.

Conditional Access requires Microsoft Entra ID P1, which is included in Microsoft 365 Business Premium and E3 or E5 plans. It lets you write your own rules: require MFA for everyone, block sign-ins from countries you don't do business in, require company managed devices for certain apps, or exempt a scanner that can't do MFA without turning off protection for everyone. You turn off security defaults when you move to Conditional Access, so the replacement policies need to be in place first.

If your tenant has neither, that's the first thing to fix. It is also the first thing many cyber insurance applications ask about.

Why block legacy authentication?

Legacy authentication means older ways of signing in, used by old email apps, some copiers and scanners and some older line of business tools. These methods only check a password and can't do MFA, so attackers use them to get around it. Security defaults and a Conditional Access block policy both shut them off.

Microsoft has also been retiring basic authentication in Exchange Online. Microsoft has announced that basic authentication for SMTP AUTH (often used by scan to email and older apps that send mail) will be disabled by default for existing tenants at the end of December 2026, though admins can turn it back on, and it plans to announce a final removal date in the second half of 2027. These dates have moved before, so check Microsoft's Exchange Team announcements. If a copier or app in your office still sends email this way, it needs an update or a different sending method before then.

Should I block auto-forwarding to outside addresses?

For most businesses, yes. One of the first things an attacker does after stealing a mailbox password is create a rule that forwards copies of email, such as invoices and payment requests, to an outside address. It keeps working even after the password is changed.

Microsoft controls this in the outbound spam filter policy. The default setting is called Automatic, system controlled, and Microsoft notes that it can behave differently from one organization to the next, so it recommends choosing On or Off explicitly. Setting it to Off blocks automatic forwarding to external recipients and also disables existing inbox rules that forward outside the company. If one person truly needs it, an admin can make a narrow exception instead of leaving it open for everyone.

How should admin accounts be set up?

Microsoft's guidance is clear: people with admin rights should do their everyday work, like email and browsing, from a regular account, and use a separate account only for admin tasks. A Global Administrator account that also reads email is a much bigger target if someone clicks a bad link.

A few more rules from Microsoft worth following:

  • Keep Global Administrators to fewer than five people. Use narrower roles, such as User Administrator or Exchange Administrator, for day to day jobs.
  • Create two emergency access accounts. These are cloud only Global Administrator accounts that aren't tied to a specific person and are kept for the day everyone else gets locked out.
  • Protect every admin with MFA. Microsoft now requires MFA to sign in to the Microsoft 365 admin center.
  • Remove admin rights when people change roles or leave. It belongs on your offboarding list.

Is audit logging turned on?

Audit logging records who signed in, who changed mailbox rules, who shared files and who changed admin settings. When something goes wrong, it's how you find out what happened. Microsoft says audit log search is turned on by default for most organizations, and for users without an E5 license, Audit (Standard) keeps records for 180 days. It can be switched off, though, and tenants set up long ago are worth checking. Your IT provider can confirm it with one command or in the Microsoft Purview portal.

What if we have Defender for Office 365?

Microsoft 365 Business Premium includes Microsoft Defender for Office 365 Plan 1, which adds protection like Safe Links (checking links when they're clicked) and Safe Attachments (opening attachments in a safe space before delivery) and stronger protection against impersonation.

If you have it, the simplest step is to turn on Microsoft's Standard or Strict preset security policies, which apply Microsoft's recommended settings and update automatically as Microsoft changes its recommendations. Microsoft also recommends setting up SPF, DKIM and DMARC for every domain you send email from, which helps keep criminals from sending email that looks like it came from you.

Who sees Microsoft's security alerts?

Microsoft 365 includes default alert policies that flag things like a new forwarding or redirect rule, a user being added to an Exchange admin role, suspicious email sending patterns and a user being restricted from sending email (often a sign the account was taken over). The alerts only help if they reach someone who acts on them. Check who receives the notifications, and make sure that person or your help desk knows what to do next. If an alert follows a click on a suspicious email, our guide on what to do after clicking a phishing link walks through the first steps.

Security settings protect your accounts. They don't replace a backup of your data, which is a separate job covered in does Microsoft 365 back up your email and files?

FAQ

Are Microsoft 365 security defaults enough for a small business?

For many very small offices, security defaults are a solid baseline at no cost. If you need exceptions, location rules or device requirements, Conditional Access gives you that control.

Will turning on MFA lock people out?

Not if you plan it. Tell users ahead of time, help them set up the Microsoft Authenticator app and keep emergency access accounts ready in case an admin gets stuck.

Does Microsoft 365 Business Standard include Conditional Access?

No. Business Standard doesn't include Microsoft Entra ID P1, so Conditional Access requires Business Premium or an add-on license. Security defaults work on Business Standard.

How often should these settings be reviewed?

At least once a year, and any time you change licenses, add an admin or bring on a new IT provider. Microsoft changes defaults over time, so a tenant that was right two years ago may not be today.

Get your Microsoft 365 settings reviewed

TechCore supports Microsoft 365 and other cloud services for businesses in Smyrna, Nashville, Middle Tennessee and Chattanooga, backed by a local help desk. Request a free IT assessment and we'll check your MFA setup, sign-in policies, forwarding rules, admin accounts and alerts, and give you a clear list of what to change.

Cloud services

Cloud apps, backup and recovery planned around access and risk.

Learn about cloud services

Want a second opinion on your setup?

Book a free walkthrough with a local TechCore tech.

Smyrna & Chattanooga(615) 237-5700Call now Smyrna (Nashville & Middle TN) office
Talk to TechCore

Need help with your IT?

Send a quick message and our IT team will get back to you. Prefer to talk? Call us now.

Smyrna & Chattanooga(615) 237-5700Call now Smyrna (Nashville & Middle TN) office

Fields marked with an asterisk are required.